Skip to main content

Misconception: Surrogacy relationships are impersonal and transactional



Picture a snowy corner of Northern Ontario, sitting down with gentle grace in the early hours of a Saturday morning, Martha, a surrogate mother, held her firstborn – a baby girl. Not her child, of course, but the baby she had carried for a gay couple from Toronto. As she handed over the precious bundle of joy to the couple, she experienced a profound connection remarkably different from the alleged detached and impersonal nature of surrogacy relationships. 


There is a prevailing misconception that surrogacy relationships are transactional, devoid of any personal connection or emotional depth. However, in reality, the terrain of modern-day surrogacy is overwhelmingly landscaped with evolving emotional connections between the intended parents and surrogates. 


So where did this impersonal and transactional illusion spring from? To understand this, we must first glance back over our shoulder into the past. 


Historically, surrogacy was a rather impersonal process. In its nascent form, surrogacy arrangements were often anonymous. Similar to adoption processes some decades ago, surrogacy involved little to no contact between the surrogate and intended parents. The shroud of secrecy was thick, and the process indeed quivered close to transactional.


However, revisiting the contemporary world of surrogacy, this age-old caricature of an unemotional transaction between the surrogate and intended parents seems far away. A study on surrogacy conducted by the Centre for Family Research, University of Cambridge, cites that 88% of surrogate mothers in the sample studied reported maintaining contact with intendent parents and the child after the completion of the surrogate journey. 





Take, for instance, the narrative of Julia, another surrogate mother who teamed up with a couple from Germany. They visited her frequently, attended every prenatal examination, decorated the nursery together, and even shared family meals. Each step of the journey stitched them closer, weaving a mutual bond that outlived the surrogacy process. 


Raising voices from the scientific community, here’s what Dr. Elisa Zanatta, a major researcher on surrogacy, has to say. “Surrogacy is not a cold monetary transaction. Not in the least bit. It is about working together, creating connections, and bonding over the shared goal of bringing a life into the world,” says Dr. Zanatta. Add to this the personal accounts of surrogates, most relishing their experience as enriching, personal, and life changing, the image of impersonality gradually dims out. 


Yet, the stereotype refuses to subside. It is essential, therefore, to dive deeper into the surrogate-intended parent relationship dynamic to distill the truth. 


In practice, many surrogacy agencies provide counseling and support for both parties throughout the process. This intervention not only demystifies the journey but also equips both sides with the emotional and practical knowledge to handle the relationship's intricacies. 


Surrogacy is an intricate dance of emotions - the nervous excitement of the intended parents, the altruistic commitment of the surrogate, and the shared anticipation as they follow the baby's developmental milestones. These shared experiences foster an emotional connection that punctures the notion of surrogacy being a strictly business arrangement.


Now it’s time to take a step back and reflect. Where does this misconstrued notion of surrogacy relationships stem from? Perhaps it’s rooted in our societal discomfort with combining the sensitive subject of reproduction with commerce. Or maybe it's the oversimplification of the surrogate journey to a mere transaction that serves as a safety harness for debunking the intricate complexities involved. 


However, one cannot deny the evidence at hand - the personal narratives of surrogates and intended parents, the way the industry has evolved, and the psychological insight into these relationships.


Featuring Martha again, the delightful surrogate from Northern Ontario, who in an interview illuminated, “It's about giving something from the goodness of your heart. The money doesn't even compare to the experience.”


The waves of change in surrogacy relationships enlighten us with the evolution from detachment to rich personal involvement. Understanding the emotional dynamics of these relationships, we might just be able to wipe the foggy lens through which surrogacy is often viewed. 


Reshaping our perspectives, we may toss out the transactional tag attached unfairly to surrogacy. In its place, we may see a poignant picture painted with strokes of empathy, shared joy, strong partnership, and above all, a profound, deeply personal bond. While these connections have their complexities and challenges, they are far from impersonal and transactional – enlightening us that surrogacy is as human a journey as creating life itself.






Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Misconception: Same-sex couples face more legal hurdles in surrogacy than heterosexual couples.

Introduction It was a cold December morning when Maria handed over the newborn baby to the eagerly waiting couple, Joe and Sam. This was not Maria’s own child; she was a surrogate, and the parents were not the conventional couple you might envision. Joe and Sam were a loving, committed same-sex couple. They had turned to surrogacy under the weighty burden of a misleading perception, that as a same-sex couple, adoption would be a legal maze, much more onerous than for heterosexual counterparts. Context and Background This anecdote captures the dilemma faced by many same-sex couples who want to start a family. Joe and Sam, like many others, had set sail in the sea of surrogacy, driven by a widely held notion that same-sex couples face more substantial legal barriers in surrogacy than heterosexual couples. However, does this conventional wisdom hold water when we delve into solid research and hear from the experts? For a start, let's rewind a bit and clarify what we mean by surrogacy.

A SIMPLE GUIDE ON BECOMING A SURROGATE: 10 KEY STEPS FOR PROSPECTIVE SURROGATES

Choosing to become a surrogate is a deeply fulfilling journey which contributes in a meaningful way to the lives of others. Wherever you are located, be it Los Angeles, Boston, or a small town in between, it’s crucial to conduct your research and connect with a surrogacy agency that resonates with your expectations and comfort levels. There are multiple options out there and your physical location does not limit your choices. For those who aim to venture deeper into the understanding of surrogacy and are contemplating becoming a surrogate, here are the ten key steps integral to the surrogacy process. 1. DECIPHERING THE ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SURROGATE MOTHERS Potential surrogates must meet specific qualifications and requirements to ensure their capability and readiness to undertake surrogacy. It’s indeed a beautiful act of giving, deserving parents expecting nothing less than the mental, emotional, and physical fitness from their potential surrogate. The best starting point would be

Misconception: Surrogates face long-term psychological trauma post-delivery.

Nancy, a soft-spoken woman in her mid-thirties from California, recently made an unusual gift, one that some might consider the greatest gift of all - she gave birth to a child for a couple she barely knew. She was a gestational surrogate. Nancy was carefully screened, her psychological and physical wellbeing scrutinized before she was declared fit. A few months after the delivery, she met me for coffee: radiant, genial, and exhibiting no signs of distress, tearing the age-old tapestry of psychological trauma associated with surrogacy. Our meeting set the stage for a deeper inquiry into the commonly perceived notion: A surrogate mother is destined to suffer long-term psychological trauma post-delivery. But data and research suggest the narrative might not run that dark and deep. A growing number of women, like Nancy, are venturing into surrogacy arrangements, opening their bodies and lives to create families for others. The public narrative - often spurred by dramatic film portrayals a